← All articles

·3 min read

How to Scope an AI Pilot With Human Approval

A review-only pilot can show whether AI saves time once human corrections and exceptions are counted.

Scope an AI pilot around one task, a named reviewer and an existing manual fallback. Test labelled cases, compare review time and errors with the baseline, and agree on stop conditions before expanding.

Key takeaways

  • Use review-only mode for the initial workflow trial.
  • Define which evidence the reviewer must see.
  • Test how outstanding work moves back to the manual queue.

What belongs in the pilot brief?

FieldFictional example
TaskSuggest a category for incoming administrative requests.
ScopeOne team and a fixed list of categories, using synthetic cases for initial tests.
ReviewerShift lead accepts, corrects or declines each suggestion. A named backup covers absences.
EvidenceSource request, suggested category and the policy definition available on the review screen.
BaselineManual categorization time, correction rate and queue age over a comparable period.
FallbackSend new requests to the ordinary manual queue and reconcile those pending at the pause.
OwnershipOperations owns labels and review capacity. The delivery lead owns the switch and recovery check.

How should you build the test set?

Use labelled, held-out cases with ordinary requests, unclear wording, missing fields, repeated requests and uncommon categories. Have the process owner resolve disagreements about expected outcomes. Compare performance by category as well as overall. A large common category can hide serious errors in a smaller one.

Measure suggestions accepted as-is, incorrect suggestions that the reviewer caught and incorrect suggestions that got through. Time the reviewer from opening the request to recording the decision. Separate the time spent reading source evidence from time spent correcting suggestions. NIST AI Risk Management Framework Playbook

When should the team pause or stop?

Agree before the trial on how many errors of each type are tolerable and which events trigger immediate review. For this fictional pilot, an unapproved external update or an item missing from both queues triggers an immediate pause. The owner also pauses if the approval queue exceeds the staffing capacity agreed for the trial.

On pause, disable new suggestions, list all outstanding items, restore the normal queue and match each pending item by request ID. Test this procedure with the backup lead present. At the end of the pilot, confirm whether review time improved and which categories still need manual handling.

Bring one workflow and your current decision criteria to discuss an AI pilot with Wizy.

Frequently asked questions

Who should approve AI suggestions in a pilot?

Assign the role that already owns the decision and designate a named backup. Reviewers must be able to examine the source, correct the suggestion or decline it.

How large should an AI pilot test set be?

Start with enough labelled cases to cover the supported categories, routine requests, uncommon wording and exceptions. Review each category separately so common cases cannot mask recurring errors elsewhere.

When should an AI pilot stop?

Pause when an agreed stop condition occurs, such as an unapproved external change, a missing item or a review backlog beyond the team’s capacity. Reconcile pending cases before restarting.